Talents

We live in a world where we are tested from the time we are born.

At first the “test” is merely observation.  Do we sit up, roll-over, walk, talk and other “skills” within a normal period of time following birth.  Then we prepare to enter school.  Again a test determines our readiness, and each level thereafter, a test determines our progress.  Are we learning what we should?  Are our teachers doing their job well enough?

When we pass a test, others express pride, pat themselves on the back, and we move on to greater challenges.  There is ever another test.  Through college, into our jobs and careers, and nobody knows where the test ends.

Here are some stories about failed tests.

Case 1:

I’ve written before about having difficulties reading when I was in school in my post Difficulties.   So imagine taking a test, usually timed tests.  How well do you think I did on those tests?  For one thing, I never finished them.  I froze on tests.  I did about average, which says to me, a test, not a single one, ever came close to being a true measure of what I knew, nor what my intelligence was, nor a proper assessment of my talents.  Imagine my surprise when I did well on a computer Mensa test.

I never thought I was a genius, but I didn’t think I was stupid either.  I just didn’t apply myself, is what I was told.  I knew I could have done better, if I had finished the test.  I could have done better if I wasn’t filled with anxiety.  No-one particularly cared if I did well in school.  As a male science teacher told me, I was just going to get married and have babies, so why was I wasting his time.

Case 2:

My sister, Karen, in third grade was given the standard intelligence test.  Karen was experiencing some of the same difficulties I was experiencing.  Karen scored so low on the test that it was recommended she be transferred to a special school for the mentally challenged.  Our parents vetoed that idea, keeping Karen in the social environment of her peers.  Now study after study show that students whose teachers think of them as intelligent actually do better in school.  Karen did not have this advantage.  Karen was passed along with C’s to keep pace with her social peers.

Karen graduated high school and served in the US Army.  When her time of service ended, she enrolled in college.  Testing was part of that process.  This round of testing did not show that Karen was retarded, developmentally delayed, nor intellectually challenged.  Karen tested as an actual genius.  Unfortunately, she died shortly after.

Case 3:

Our boy was challenged, but you would never know it to sit and talk with him, leaving us to question just what are his capabilities.   No child left behind, left him in the dust.  His AEP called for oral testing, but neither his classes nor the testing was set up to either teach nor test orally.  Our boy dropped out in frustration, but found he could not get a job without a high school diploma.

Because of his AEP our boy was permitted to re-enter high school after the age of 18 and complete his high school education.  Here were the requirements of graduation:  attend classes, sit through the test and color in the circles, and graduate.  Grades, learning, passing were not factors.

He is an excellent driver, with excellent spacial perception, but can’t pass the test to get his Commercial Drivers License.  The test won’t be given orally.  A job that pays well, and that he may be perfectly suited for, is denied him because of a handicap, and no willingness of accommodation.   There may be other jobs that he is suited for, but No Child Left Behind did nothing to help him discover what that might me.  Our boy’s reading ability is the determining factor in what jobs may be available to him.  He also has severe asthma, which keeps him from a host of other jobs, like gardening, that the school tried to get him interested in.

My conclusion:

I don’t trust the results of testing.  Testing is done under a narrowly defined set of conditions, and do not consider anything that may interfere with true results, such as illness, hunger, thirst, needing to go to the bathroom, anxiety, unfamiliar language, etc.  Testing doesn’t tell us what a person is capable of, but is only a snapshot of one particular moment, that may have been a bad moment.   How hard a person works, is not tested.  The determination of a person is not tested.  Outside of a very narrow set of skills, aptitude is not tested.

I believe testing does more harm than good.  Testing may be a necessary evil, but we shouldn’t let it direct our lives, nor the lives of our children.   At best, testing is a minor tool in directing us to where our true talents lie.

I also believe the reason testing doesn’t work for children, is the same reason testing doesn’t work as a tool for determining a teachers competence as a teacher.

 

 

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Talents

Add yours

  1. I agree with you. Any test is only testing a very narrow and specific skill set or knowledge base in only one very specific way of communicating. There are, as you said so well here, many different types of intelligence that are not captured by the one size fits all tests.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

Life of an El Paso Woman

EL PASO, TEXAS PEOPLE & PLACES, MUSIC, MOVIES, LIFE, HISPANIC CULTURE, WOMEN'S ISSUES, ETC.

Darryl Callahan Media

The Canadian Bearded Blogger & Broadcaster. Bringing All Media Content To One Pace.

Elena Peters

midlife blogger & pinterest master

WELCOME TO CRYSTAL'S SITE(ORIGINALLY COUNTRY LIVING)

FAMILY, ANIMALS, COUNTRY LIVING AND MORE

Suzie Speaks

The Adventures Of a Thirty-Something Life

Phenderson Djèlí Clark

The Musings of a Disgruntled Haradrim . . .

Sidnee Shares

Find your own happiness & stay there

Ravi'S Blog

Java Fever

scauthor

The greatest WordPress.com site in all the land!

Sometimes Stellar Storyteller

Writing by numbers, outside of the lines

lifelessons - a blog by Judy Dykstra-Brown

Reflections on Life through poetry, essays and photos

The Leafy Paw

Journal on the soul of the world • Amber MV

From Sand to Gemstones

Refining Life's Ragged Edges

helen meikle's scribblefest

writer editor proofreader

Lost Property Repository

The Repository of the lost and wordless

Windblownwords

A blog about living and writing.

April's Perspective

looking at news and our lives

The Gad About Town

All posts copyright 2013–2017 by Mark Aldrich.

The Blog Propellant

Prompts to give your writing a little propulsion

artifiswords

This is where I use my words...and share with you

Boring Bug

Cogito ergo sum- I think therefore I am.

Hot White Snow

A site for my creative writing endeavors, writing prompt responses, and experimentation.

DESIGNWITHFLAIR

creativity inspired by the spontaneity of scribble

%d bloggers like this: